Their marriages were long in coming—and tragically shortened by illness. But for two same-sex couples, their unions became crucial legal litmus tests that would change the course of LGBTQ rights in America.
It was the union of Edith (“Edie”) Windsor and Thea Spyer, together for 40 years before they legally married, which prompted the 2013 United States v. Windsor ruling—which mandated federal spousal benefits for same-sex couples. Two years later, the Obergefell v. Hodges decision would forever alter the definition of marriage in the U.S. It validated, once and for all, the union of Jim Obergefell and John Arthur, a Cincinnati couple who had raced a deadly disease to wed on an airport tarmac, only to have their marriage nullified by restrictive state law.
United States v. Windsor: Edie & Thea
In 2007, a terminal diagnosis prompted Edie Windsor and Thea Spyer to fly to Toronto, Canada—where, surrounded by a handful of friends, they were married by Canada’s first openly gay judge. Spyer, wheelchair-bound, was dressed in all black; Windsor, in all white, sat on her lap.
Their love story began in 1963 when Windsor, who had recently divorced and moved to New York to attend graduate school in mathematics, asked a friend to bring her to a spot where lesbians hung out. They went to a Greenwich Village restaurant called Portofino, where she was introduced to Spyer, a young psychologist. Later that night, they ended up at Spyer’s apartment with a bunch of friends.
“She danced a hole into the bottom of her stockings,” Spyer recounted in the 2009 documentary “Edie & Thea: A Very Long Engagement.”
Windsor was interested in an exclusive relationship immediately, but felt conflicted. Given the social pressures of the time, she struggled with her sexuality and even attended group therapy to try and help her live a “straight” life. Spyer, meanwhile, wanted to play the field.
READ MORE: Women Got 'Married' Long Before Gay Marriage